Florida Criminal Defense
November 22, 2026
10 min read
Aaron M. Cohen

Pizza Doxxing a Judge Is a Felony in Florida: How Prosecutors Charge It and What the Defense Can Challenge

Questioned about a pizza order sent to a judge? Florida charges it under § 817.568, up to 15 years when the target is a judge. See what the defense challenges.
Share this analysis:
Watch · Canceled Before Delivery · 0:47

Two online pizza orders, placed on consecutive days in March 2025, carried the names, personal phone numbers and work email addresses of two Hillsborough County judges, with delivery to their homes. One order included a $150 cash tip for the driver to knock loudly. According to the arrest affidavit, both judges learned of the orders and canceled them before delivery.

A pizza delivery driver holds an unmarked box on the front step of a quiet suburban Tampa house at night under a porch light

Florida prosecutors have charged pizza doxxing as fraudulent use of personal identification information, a felony, even when the orders were canceled before delivery.

In May 2026, the man who placed them pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 22 months in Florida state prison, followed by two years of probation. The charges did not allege a threat. They alleged identity fraud, and that choice shows how Florida prosecutes what has come to be called pizza doxxing. If a detective, a deputy U.S. marshal or an FBI agent is asking you about a delivery order, a posted address or an account opened in someone else's name, this is the framework you are facing.

Key Takeaways

  • Florida prosecutors have charged pizza doxxing as fraudulent use of personal identification information under Fla. Stat. § 817.568(2)(a), a five-year felony.
  • When the target is a judge or other public servant, § 817.568(11) makes the same conduct a second-degree felony punishable by up to 15 years.
  • Using someone's information for the purpose of harassing them is a first-degree misdemeanor under § 817.568(4), and that line is worth fighting over.
  • A 2026 Hillsborough County case ended in 22 months in prison even though, according to the affidavit, both orders were canceled before delivery.
  • Repeated deliveries, or deliveries to federal judges, can also bring federal cyberstalking charges under 18 U.S.C. § 2261A, investigated by the FBI and U.S. Marshals.

What Happened in the Hillsborough County Pizza Doxxing Case

The facts come from the sheriff's affidavit, as reported by the Florida Bar News, and from the Tampa Bay Times coverage of the sentencing. Each order was placed online with a national pizza chain and directed to a judge's home. Each used the judge's own name and contact details. Both judges had recently ruled in matters involving the man who placed them. One had set a hearing on an injunction in which he was the respondent. The other had entered a final judgment against him the same day the first order went in.

Sheriff's investigators subpoenaed the ordering records, then the internet provider. Both orders traced to the same IP address, and he was the subscriber on the account. A witness placed a computer and his own internet service at that address. He was arrested a few weeks later on two counts of fraudulent use of personal information. The Chief Justice of the Florida Supreme Court moved the case out of the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit, and the Governor reassigned the prosecution to the State Attorney for the Twelfth Circuit. He pleaded guilty on the day he was set to go to trial.

🚨 Case Alert

He pleaded guilty on the day he was set to go to trial and was sentenced in May 2026 to 22 months in Florida state prison, followed by two years of probation. According to the affidavit, both orders were canceled before delivery.

The Hillsborough case stands out because it ended in a conviction. Researchers at the Berkeley Judicial Institute and NYU's Rule of Law Lab have counted nearly 200 anonymous pizza deliveries to federal judges since 2025, and the report's authors found no public record of a federal arrest. We cover that side of the problem in our companion analysis of pizza doxxing and federal judges.

Hands type on a laptop in a dark room, the screen glowing cyan with a blank order form, a phone and a crumpled receipt beside it
An online order leaves a trail: the account, the email address, the phone number, the payment method, the device and the IP address.

What Florida Prosecutors and Investigators Are Building

Florida's courts no longer treat these deliveries as pranks. In 2025 the Florida Supreme Court created a Workgroup on Judicial Security and directed it to study threat detection, threat response and the release of judges' personal information, with a final report due May 29, 2026. The chief judge in Hillsborough County has said he reports every incident to the sheriff, whether or not it includes an overt threat. Hillsborough sits in the Middle District of Florida, and the U.S. Attorney's Office there has said publicly that it investigates every threat against court personnel.

The investigation itself is not complicated, and that is the point. An online order leaves a trail: the account, the email address, the phone number, the payment method, the device, the IP address, the store's order ticket, the driver's delivery record and, often, a doorbell camera. Detectives subpoena the restaurant or ordering platform first and the internet provider second. In Hillsborough, that sequence produced an arrest within weeks.

Detectives subpoena the restaurant or ordering platform first and the internet provider second. In Hillsborough, that sequence produced an arrest within weeks.
A sheriff's detective at a desk at night reviews subpoena returns and a neighborhood map with one house circled in red beside an internet router

Motive drives the case. Investigators start with people who have a matter in front of the judge or who recently lost one. If you are a litigant, a party to a family or injunction case, or someone who has posted about a judge, assume you are on that list before anyone calls you.

Expect the case to leave the county. When the target sits in the local courthouse, the case is likely to be reassigned to another circuit and another State Attorney, as it was in Hillsborough. That changes the prosecutor, the judge and the logistics.

The Charges and the Exposure Under Florida Law

Florida has no statute named for pizza doxxing. Prosecutors choose from several, and the choice sets the exposure.

  • Fla. Stat. § 817.568(2)(a), fraudulent use of personal identification information. A third-degree felony, punishable by up to five years in prison under § 775.082. The statute's definition of personal identification information includes a name, a postal or email address and a telephone number. This is the charge listed in the Hillsborough arrest affidavit.
  • § 817.568(11), the public-servant enhancement. Fraudulent use of the personal information of a public servant, which § 838.014 defines to include judicial branch officers, is a second-degree felony punishable by up to 15 years.
  • § 817.568(5), the public-records reclassification. If a public record facilitated the offense, the charge moves up one degree. Where the address came from matters.
  • § 817.568(4), harassment by use of personal identification information. Using someone's information without consent for the purpose of harassing that person is a first-degree misdemeanor, punishable by up to one year.
  • § 784.048, stalking and aggravated stalking. Repeated deliveries can be charged as stalking, a misdemeanor. Add a credible threat, which the statute says can be nonverbal and implied by a pattern of conduct, and the charge becomes aggravated stalking, a third-degree felony. A prior injunction raises the stakes further; see how HB 277 changed Florida's injunction-violation rules.
  • § 836.10, written or electronic threats. A note or message sent with an order that threatens to kill or do bodily harm is a second-degree felony.
  • § 836.115, cyberintimidation by publication. Posting a person's information online with intent that others use it to threaten or harass is a first-degree misdemeanor. It reaches the person who posts a judge's address, not necessarily the person who places an order.
⚖️ Key Legal Point

Fraudulent use of the personal information of a public servant, which § 838.014 defines to include judicial branch officers, is a second-degree felony punishable by up to 15 years.

When a Florida Case Becomes a Federal Case

Every conviction under § 817.568 also carries a mandatory $1,001 surcharge the court cannot waive, and a stalking sentence can include a no-contact order lasting up to 10 years. Federal law reaches the same conduct. 18 U.S.C. § 2261A makes cyberstalking a federal crime carrying up to five years, and 18 U.S.C. § 1028(a)(7) covers use of another person's identifying information in connection with a state felony. The mandatory two-year term for aggravated identity theft under 18 U.S.C. § 1028A does not attach, because neither stalking nor § 1028(a)(7) is one of its listed predicates. A Florida investigation can become a case where you are facing federal charges without any new conduct.

Critical Mistakes People Make Early

These cases are often decided before an arrest, and usually by the person under investigation.

  • Explaining it as a joke. "It was a prank" admits you placed the order. Why you did it is evidence of intent, and intent can decide whether the State files a misdemeanor or a felony.
  • Deleting the app, the account or the messages. Once you know about an investigation, destroying records can be charged separately as tampering with evidence under § 918.13, a third-degree felony.
  • Contacting the judge. An apology or an explanation is another contact. It can be charged as one more act in a course of conduct, and if you have a case before that judge it creates a second problem.
  • Posting about it. Every post about the judge, the case or the investigation is a statement the State can use.
  • Assuming a canceled order means no crime. According to the affidavit, the Hillsborough orders were canceled. The sentence was 22 months.
  • Waiting for the arrest. By the time a warrant issues, the State has already chosen the charge.
A defendant stands with head bowed at the defense podium of a Florida county courtroom as the judge's bench sits in silhouette above

By the time a warrant issues, the State has already chosen the charge.

How These Cases Are Defended

The defense of a pizza doxxing case starts with three questions: who placed the order, what the State can prove about why, and which statute fits.

Identity. An IP address identifies an internet account, not the person at the keyboard. Households share connections. Accounts get borrowed, shared or compromised. Phone numbers get spoofed. The State has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you placed the order, and subscriber records alone do not always get it there.

🛡️ Defense Strategy

An IP address identifies an internet account, not the person at the keyboard. The State has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you placed the order, and subscriber records alone do not always get it there.

The felony and misdemeanor line. The felony in § 817.568(2)(a) requires that the information be used fraudulently. The Legislature wrote a separate misdemeanor in § 817.568(4) for using the same information for the purpose of harassing. When the State's own theory is intimidation rather than gain, the defense can argue the misdemeanor is the offense the Legislature wrote for this conduct. Florida's rule of lenity in § 775.021(1) requires an ambiguous criminal statute to be construed in favor of the accused. That argument was never tested in Hillsborough because the case ended in a plea.

Threat charges and the First Amendment. If the State charges aggravated stalking or a written threat, it must prove a true threat. Under Counterman v. Colorado (2023), the prosecution has to show at least that the speaker consciously disregarded a substantial risk that the communication would be viewed as threatening violence. A pizza with no message is ambiguous, and ambiguity is a defense.

Resolution. Where the facts support it, the work turns to the charge and the record: a misdemeanor plea in place of a felony, a withheld adjudication, a mental health evaluation, or a no-contact agreement that answers the court's safety concern. None of that is available after a jury verdict on a second-degree felony. Our Florida and federal identity theft defense practice handles these charges in state and federal court.

Federal exposure. Before resolving a state case, find out whether the FBI or the U.S. Marshals Service is involved. A state plea, and anything said at it, can be used in a later federal prosecution, and a state judgment does not bar federal charges. If you are under federal investigation at the same time, the two cases have to be handled as one strategy.

Why Timing Matters Right Now

The charging decision in these cases is made early, usually when the State Attorney's office reviews the arrest affidavit and decides what to file. That is when attribution problems, mitigation and the misdemeanor argument carry the most weight. After the information is filed, the State is defending a decision it has already made.

The pressure runs the other way, too. Florida's judiciary and Congress are both focused on threats to judges. A bipartisan federal bill, the Stop the Doxx Act, would create a new federal felony for doxxing state and local judges as well as federal ones. If a deputy marshal or an FBI agent is already involved, a federal target letter may follow, and the work to avoid indictment starts before it arrives. Prosecutors know a conviction sends a message. A person under investigation needs counsel working before that message is written into a charging document.

Common Questions

Is pizza doxxing a crime in Florida?

Sending a pizza is not a crime. Placing an order with someone else's name, phone number or email address without consent can be. Florida prosecutors have charged it as fraudulent use of personal identification information under Fla. Stat. § 817.568(2)(a), a third-degree felony, and it becomes a second-degree felony under § 817.568(11) when the target is a judge or other public servant. Repeated deliveries can also support stalking charges under § 784.048.

What is the penalty for pizza doxxing a judge in Florida?

A third-degree felony under § 817.568(2)(a) carries up to five years in prison. Under § 817.568(11), using a public servant's information makes it a second-degree felony with up to 15 years. The harassment offense in § 817.568(4) is a misdemeanor punishable by up to one year. Every conviction under the statute carries a mandatory $1,001 surcharge. In the 2026 Hillsborough County case, the sentence was 22 months in prison plus two years of probation.

Can I be charged if the pizza was never delivered?

Yes. Under Fla. Stat. § 817.568, the offense is the unauthorized use of another person's identifying information, and it is complete when the order is placed with that information. Delivery is not an element. In the Hillsborough County case, the arrest affidavit says both judges canceled the orders before delivery, and the man who placed them still pleaded guilty and received 22 months in prison.

Can a Florida pizza doxxing case become a federal case?

Yes. Federal cyberstalking under 18 U.S.C. § 2261A reaches a course of conduct carried out over the internet with intent to harass or intimidate, and it carries up to five years. Federal prosecutors are a separate sovereign, so a state plea does not bar federal charges. Deliveries aimed at federal judges, or orders placed across state lines, draw the FBI and the U.S. Marshals Service.

Should I talk to a detective who asks about a delivery order?

Not before you speak with a lawyer. Your explanation of why an order was placed is evidence of intent, and in a § 817.568 case intent can decide whether the charge is a misdemeanor or a felony. You may decline an interview and give the detective your lawyer's contact information. Do not delete accounts or messages in the meantime; that can be charged as tampering with evidence under § 918.13.

Under Investigation for Doxxing, Stalking or Threat Allegations in Florida?

If a detective, a deputy U.S. marshal or an FBI agent has contacted you about a delivery order, a posted address or contact with a judge, the decisions that matter most are the early ones. As a Palm Beach County criminal defense attorney with a federal practice in the Southern and Middle Districts of Florida, Aaron M. Cohen represents clients in state and federal investigations throughout Florida and nationwide, with the discretion these matters require. Contact AMC Defense Law at 561-542-5494 or amc@amcdefenselaw.com to arrange a confidential consultation.

Aaron M. Cohen, criminal defense attorney, advising a tense client in a dark hoodie across a conference table with a closed laptop between them

Aaron M. Cohen represents clients in state and federal doxxing, stalking and threat investigations throughout Florida.

If you or your loved ones have been arrested or are under investigation, call Aaron M. Cohen, 24 hours a day to get help.

About the author. Aaron M. Cohen is the founder and principal attorney of AMC Defense Law, a criminal defense firm in Boca Raton, Florida, with more than 30 years of experience in state and federal courts. He is admitted to practice in Florida, New York, New Jersey, and the District of Columbia, and before the United States District Courts for the Southern and Middle Districts of Florida, the Southern, Eastern, and Western Districts of New York, the District of New Jersey, and the Northern District of Texas. He appears pro hac vice in other federal districts nationwide. The firm represents clients in federal investigations and prosecutions involving healthcare fraud, Anti-Kickback Statute matters, DME and telemedicine fraud, peptide and compounded-drug enforcement, controlled-substance and drug conspiracy cases, financial crimes, and complex federal litigation, in Florida and nationwide.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change, and outcomes depend on the specific facts of each case. If you are under investigation or facing charges, consult a qualified attorney about your situation.

Aaron M. Cohen, Principal Attorney

Aaron M. Cohen

Principal Attorney

Aaron M. Cohen is a nationally recognized criminal defense attorney with over 30 years of experience representing individuals and entities in complex criminal investigations and prosecutions across the United States.

View Attorney Profile
How we defend these cases
Continue reading
30+ Years of Federal & State Defense Experience

Need Expert Legal Defense?

Facing federal gun or drug charges in South Florida? The DOJ's aggressive enforcement climate demands experienced federal defense counsel. Our team understands the complex intersection of firearms and narcotics law.

All consultations are completely confidential