Federal Sentencing
November 17, 2026
9 min read
Aaron M. Cohen

Restitution in a Federal Fraud Conspiracy: Why You Can Owe the Entire Loss, and the Objection That Must Be Made at Sentencing

Facing sentencing in a federal fraud conspiracy? The Eleventh Circuit just upheld a $16.9 million joint order with no bank tracing. Learn the objection to make.
Share this analysis:
Watch · Every Dollar · 1:29

A restitution order in a federal fraud conspiracy can follow you for decades, and it can be entered for every dollar the scheme lost, not just the dollars you touched. On November 2, 2026, the Eleventh Circuit affirmed a $16,958,372 restitution order against a man convicted of conspiracy to commit mail fraud in a pandemic unemployment insurance scheme, most of it joint and several with his co-conspirators. His appeal argued that nobody ever traced the money to him. The court answered that he never said so in the district court, and the record supported the order anyway.

Federal fraud conspiracy defendant standing at the defense table after sentencing as stacks of unemployment claim files spill toward him, joint and several restitution

A joint and several restitution order can reach every dollar the scheme lost.

Key Takeaways

  • Under 18 U.S.C. § 3664(h), a federal judge may make each conspirator liable for the full restitution amount or apportion it among defendants.
  • The Mandatory Victims Restitution Act, 18 U.S.C. § 3663A(a)(2), reaches losses caused by the whole conspiracy, not only the counts of conviction.
  • A restitution objection not made at the sentencing hearing is reviewed only for plain error on appeal, a standard that rarely produces relief.
  • Eleventh Circuit law binds every federal court in Florida, so this rule governs restitution in the Southern, Middle and Northern Districts.
  • No bank tracing was required; findings that the defendant built the scheme's tools and managed others supported attributing a $16.9 million loss.

What the Eleventh Circuit Decided

The case is No. 25-14537, an unpublished per curiam opinion out of the Middle District of Georgia. A company that had closed and never had an employee was used to open an employer account on Georgia's unemployment portal in 2020. It filed roughly 7,300 claims on about 4,900 Social Security numbers, and the state paid out around $16 million. A jury convicted the account's creator of conspiracy under 18 U.S.C. § 1349 to commit mail fraud under 18 U.S.C. § 1341. The guideline range was 168 to 210 months. The judge varied down to 120 months and ordered $16,958,372 in restitution.

🚨 Case Alert

On November 2, 2026, the Eleventh Circuit affirmed a $16,958,372 restitution order, most of it joint and several, without any bank tracing or forensic accounting tying particular losses to the defendant.

On appeal the defense argued that the court had to make individualized findings about the scope of his own jointly undertaken activity, and that the government offered no bank tracing, no forensic accounting and no proof tying particular losses to him. The panel held the argument was never raised below, applied plain error review, and found no error at all. The sentencing judge had found that he created the portals and managed others as one of the leaders, and the loss figures in the presentence report were uncontested. That was enough.

The panel also addressed a published Eleventh Circuit decision from earlier this year, 163 F.4th 1346 (11th Cir. 2026), which holds that the scope of a defendant's jointly undertaken activity is not necessarily the scope of the whole conspiracy. The court read that decision as requiring reliable and specific evidence connecting the defendant to the losses, not as a new rule. Here that evidence was in the record, and the defense never contested it.

The loss figures in the presentence report were uncontested. That was enough.
Presentence report binder open under a desk lamp with an uncapped red pen beside it, uncontested federal restitution figures

What Prosecutors Build at Restitution

In a multi-defendant federal case, the government's restitution figure usually comes off the same spreadsheet as the guideline loss number. Agents total the claims paid, the presentence report adopts the total, and the prosecutor asks for joint and several liability. In South Florida healthcare fraud defense work, the payee is usually Medicare, Medicaid or a private insurer, and the figure is the amount paid on claims the government calls false.

Prosecutors do not need to follow dollars into your account. The opinion says so directly: nothing required the government to trace particular dollars into the defendant's pocket. What they need is a finding that the loss was closely related to the scheme and proximately caused by conduct within it. A role finding at sentencing, such as an aggravating role adjustment under the Guidelines Manual, does double duty and supports the restitution attribution too.

Federal agents mapping co-conspirators on a corkboard with every red string converging on one silhouette, conspiracy role finding
"The restitution number and the role fight are the same fight. If the judge finds you built the scheme or supervised others, the full loss follows."— Aaron M. Cohen, AMC Defense Law

Exposure: What the Statutes Allow

Three statutes control. 18 U.S.C. § 3663A makes restitution mandatory for property offenses committed by fraud or deceit, which covers mail fraud, wire fraud under 18 U.S.C. § 1343 and health care fraud under 18 U.S.C. § 1347. For a conspiracy, section 3663A(a)(2) reaches anyone directly harmed by the defendant's criminal conduct in the course of the scheme.

Section 3664(f)(1)(A) requires the court to order the full amount of each loss without considering the defendant's economic circumstances. Ability to pay affects the payment schedule, not the amount. Section 3664(h) then gives the judge a choice: hold each defendant liable for the full amount, or apportion liability to reflect each defendant's contribution and economic circumstances.

⚖️ Key Legal Point

Ability to pay affects the payment schedule, not the amount. Under section 3664(f)(1)(A), the court orders the full amount of each loss.

Restitution does not end with the prison term. Under 18 U.S.C. § 3613(b) and (f), liability lasts twenty years from judgment or twenty years after release from imprisonment, whichever is later, and the government enforces it with liens on property. A criminal restitution obligation is generally not dischargeable in bankruptcy under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(13). A joint and several order lets the government collect the entire balance from whichever defendant has assets, and in practice that is the one with a house, a business or a retirement account.

Suburban house at dusk under a lien notice and the shadow of chains, federal restitution enforced for twenty years after release
Liability lasts twenty years from judgment or twenty years after release from imprisonment, whichever is later.

Mistakes That Lock In the Full Loss

  • Answering "no objection." In this case the defendant was asked after sentence was imposed whether he had objections, and he said no. That answer turned a contestable attribution question into a plain error appeal under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 52(b).
  • Leaving the presentence report alone. Under Rule 32(i)(3)(A), the court may accept any undisputed portion of the report as a finding of fact. An unchallenged loss table becomes the restitution order.
  • Treating restitution as an afterthought. Prison ends. The restitution judgment does not.
  • Talking to agents first. Here the defendant denied creating the account, then admitted it. Statements like that feed role findings.
  • Signing a plea that stipulates the whole loss. Plea agreements in conspiracy cases often include a restitution figure for the entire scheme. Once it is in the agreement, it is very hard to walk back.

How We Fight Restitution Before and at Sentencing

The best restitution work happens before charges. A federal target letter attorney or grand jury investigation attorney who engages early can present facts on role, timing and loss to the prosecutor while the scope of the charged conspiracy is still being drawn. A pre-charge negotiation with the AUSA often decides what loss is later attributed.

After a conviction or plea, the fight moves to the presentence report. Rule 32(f) gives the defense 14 days after disclosure to object in writing. Those objections should dispute the loss amount, separate actual loss from intended loss, claim credits for legitimate services in health care cases, and invoke the 2026 published decision's requirement of reliable and specific evidence tying the client to each category of loss.

🛡️ Defense Strategy

Ask for apportionment under section 3664(h). Contest the role adjustment. State the restitution objection on the record, with its ground, when the judge asks for objections after imposing sentence.

Then ask for apportionment under section 3664(h), with evidence of the client's actual contribution and finances. Contest the role adjustment, because the role finding is what carries the full loss. And when the judge asks for objections after imposing sentence, state the restitution objection on the record with its ground. A federal sentencing attorney who does those three things gives the client a real appeal instead of a plain error appeal.

Why Timing Matters

Restitution exposure narrows in stages and then locks. The charging decision defines the scheme. The presentence report defines the loss. The hearing defines what the appeals court will review. Miss a stage and the next one inherits the government's number.

Florida cases move this way faster than most. Federal health care fraud investigations in the Southern District of Florida now arrive with loss figures already built from claims data, so the number exists before anyone is charged. Federal investigation defense that starts at the first subpoena or agent visit has the most room to work.

Common Questions

Can I be ordered to pay restitution for the whole conspiracy even if I received only a small share?

Yes. Under 18 U.S.C. § 3664(h), a federal judge may hold each defendant liable for the full amount or apportion liability among defendants. In November 2026 the Eleventh Circuit affirmed a $16.9 million joint and several order without any bank tracing, because the record showed the defendant created the scheme's tools and managed others. Apportionment must be requested, with evidence, at sentencing.

What happens if my lawyer does not object to restitution at sentencing?

The objection is forfeited, and the appeals court reviews it only for plain error under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 52(b). The defendant must show an error that is plain, that affected substantial rights, and that seriously affects the fairness of the proceedings. In the November 2026 Eleventh Circuit case, the unpreserved claim failed. Objections belong in the written presentence report response and again at the hearing.

Does federal restitution go away after I finish my prison sentence?

No. Under 18 U.S.C. § 3613(b) and (f), liability to pay restitution lasts twenty years from judgment or twenty years after release from imprisonment, whichever is later. The government can record liens on property and garnish wages. Criminal restitution is generally not dischargeable in bankruptcy under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(13), so the order outlasts supervised release.

Is restitution the same as the loss amount used for my sentencing guidelines?

Not always. Guideline loss under §2B1.1 can include intended loss, while restitution under 18 U.S.C. § 3663A must rest on actual loss proximately caused by the conduct. The two numbers usually start from the same government spreadsheet, which is why a loss amount dispute should be raised for both purposes in the written objections to the presentence report.

Should I hire a lawyer before I am charged in a federal fraud investigation?

Yes. The scope of the conspiracy the government charges, and the loss it later attributes to you, are shaped before the indictment is returned. A federal criminal defense attorney retained after a target letter, grand jury subpoena or agent visit can present facts on role and loss to the prosecutor while the charging decision is still open.

Facing a Federal Fraud Conspiracy Charge in Florida?

If you are under federal investigation or have been charged in a multi-defendant fraud case, the restitution number is being built now, alongside the prison exposure. AMC Defense Law represents clients in federal wire fraud, mail fraud and health care fraud matters in Palm Beach County, Broward, Miami and federal courts nationwide. A white collar defense attorney who knows how these numbers are built can begin testing them before they reach the judge. Every inquiry is handled with discretion. Contact the firm for a confidential consultation.

If you or your loved ones have been arrested or are under federal investigation, call Aaron M. Cohen, 24 hours a day to get help.

Aaron M. Cohen, bald federal criminal defense attorney in a charcoal suit and purple tie, making a restitution objection at a courtroom lectern

State the restitution objection on the record, with its ground.

About the author. Aaron M. Cohen is the founder and principal attorney of AMC Defense Law, a criminal defense firm in Boca Raton, Florida, with more than 30 years of experience in state and federal courts. He is admitted to practice in Florida, New York, New Jersey, and the District of Columbia, and before the United States District Courts for the Southern and Middle Districts of Florida, the Southern, Eastern, and Western Districts of New York, the District of New Jersey, and the Northern District of Texas. He appears pro hac vice in other federal districts nationwide. The firm represents clients in federal investigations and prosecutions involving healthcare fraud, Anti-Kickback Statute matters, DME and telemedicine fraud, peptide and compounded-drug enforcement, controlled-substance and drug conspiracy cases, financial crimes, and complex federal litigation, in Florida and nationwide.

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case turns on its own facts, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The case discussed is summarized from the public opinion. If you have questions about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

Aaron M. Cohen, Principal Attorney

Aaron M. Cohen

Principal Attorney

Aaron M. Cohen is a nationally recognized criminal defense attorney with over 30 years of experience representing individuals and entities in complex criminal investigations and prosecutions across the United States.

View Attorney Profile
How we defend these cases
Continue reading
30+ Years of Federal & State Defense Experience

Need Expert Legal Defense?

Facing federal gun or drug charges in South Florida? The DOJ's aggressive enforcement climate demands experienced federal defense counsel. Our team understands the complex intersection of firearms and narcotics law.

All consultations are completely confidential