Home/Practice Areas/Medicare and Healthcare Fraud Defense
Federal Criminal Defense

Medicare and Healthcare Fraud Defense Attorney

Federal healthcare fraud cases are built from claims data before anyone is interviewed. By the time HHS-OIG or FBI agents knock, the government usually has months or years of billing analysis, and often a cooperating insider. The defense has to start where the government started: the data, the medical records that support or undercut medical necessity, and the financial relationships behind the referrals.

Reviewed by · Updated

  • Aaron M. Cohen, more than 30 years of federal criminal defense. Healthcare fraud investigations and prosecutions nationwide.
Healthcare Fraud

Healthcare Fraud Enforcement in 2026

On June 23, 2026, the Department of Justice announced its 2026 National Health Care Fraud Takedown: 455 defendants charged across 56 federal districts, including 90 doctors and other licensed medical professionals, in cases alleging more than $6.5 billion in false claims. The cases centered on wound care and skin substitutes, telemedicine, durable medical equipment, genetic testing, opioid diversion, behavioral health, hospice, and cardiovascular testing. The Southern District of Florida remains one of the most active healthcare fraud districts in the country.

How Healthcare Fraud Investigations Start

  • Data analytics. DOJ and HHS-OIG flag providers whose billing stands out from their peers.
  • Contractor audits. A UPIC or other Medicare contractor audit, records request, or payment suspension (42 C.F.R. § 405.371) often comes first. An audit that looks administrative can be feeding a criminal referral.
  • Whistleblowers. Employees, billers, and competitors file qui tam suits under the False Claims Act, which are sealed while the government investigates.
  • Cooperators. Marketers, office managers, and co-owners who were approached first and agreed to help.
  • Subpoenas and demands. HHS-OIG subpoenas, civil investigative demands, and grand jury subpoenas for records.
  • Agent visits. HHS-OIG and FBI agents interviewing staff, patients, and referral sources, or the provider directly.

The Charges We Defend

Florida

Federal

Civil and administrative, running alongside

  • False Claims Act liability with treble damages and per-claim penalties (31 U.S.C. § 3729)
  • Exclusion from Medicare and Medicaid (42 U.S.C. § 1320a-7), license action, and DEA registration issues

Healthcare Fraud Cases We Handle

DME and orthotic brace fraud. Telemedicine and telehealth fraud. Genetic and cancer genomic testing. Anti-Kickback and Stark issues. Wound care and skin substitutes. Laboratory billing. Hospice and home health. Behavioral health, substance abuse treatment, and sober homes. Pharmacy and compounding fraud. Controlled substance prescribing.

AI-Generated Records and Health Care Fraud

AI scribes, templated notes, and AI summaries are lawful and increasingly common. The exposure is a chart that describes care that did not happen, or a note a provider signed without reading. In July 2026, four Minnesota defendants pleaded guilty to wire fraud after using ChatGPT to fabricate Medicaid records requested by insurers, and DOJ called AI use "a burgeoning trend" in health care fraud.

The most dangerous moment is the records request. Creating or completing records after a payer, contractor, or auditor asks for them can turn an overpayment dispute into a charge under 18 U.S.C. § 1519, which carries up to 20 years, and add an obstruction increase at sentencing. Preserve everything, including AI tool logs, and have counsel review records before anything is produced.

More: AI-Enabled Fraud Defense

How Healthcare Fraud Cases Are Defended

  • Intent. Health care fraud requires proof that the defendant knowingly and willfully executed a scheme to defraud. Billing errors, reliance on coders and compliance staff, and good-faith clinical judgment are not crimes.
  • Medical necessity. The government's reviewers often second-guess treating physicians from a file. Independent clinical review and the full patient record regularly tell a different story.
  • Safe harbors and structure. Many payment arrangements fit an Anti-Kickback safe harbor or fall outside the statute entirely. The documents and the actual flow of money matter more than labels.
  • Loss. The sentencing guidelines treat the amount billed as evidence of intended loss, which is why the loss number usually drives the sentence more than any other factor. We attack that number with data of our own.
  • Timing. The strongest defense work happens before indictment, when the government is still deciding whom to charge and for what.

Who We Represent

Physicians and specialists. Nurse practitioners and physician assistants. Pharmacists and pharmacy owners. Clinic, lab, DME, hospice, and home health owners. Billing and coding companies. Marketers and management companies. Hospital and health system executives. Investors in healthcare businesses.

Healthcare Fraud Defense Nationwide

Healthcare fraud is prosecuted in every federal district, and the Strike Force model concentrates cases in a handful of them. AMC Defense Law represents providers and executives in Florida, New York, New Jersey, North Carolina, Texas, California, and other federal districts, appearing pro hac vice where required.

Who Handles Your Case

Aaron M. Cohen has defended federal healthcare fraud, Anti-Kickback, DME, telemedicine, and controlled substance cases for more than 30 years. Our team includes a federal investigations consultant who is a former FBI Supervisory Special Agent and a Certified Public Accountant licensed in Ohio and Florida, with a career investigating healthcare fraud and complex financial crime, and a sentencing strategist who works on mitigation and loss analysis from the start of the case.

Frequently Asked Questions

Health care fraud under 18 U.S.C. § 1347 carries up to 10 years in prison per count, up to 20 years if the fraud results in serious bodily injury, and up to life if it results in death. Most cases also include conspiracy, kickback, or money laundering counts, restitution, forfeiture, and exclusion from federal health programs.

Yes. Contractor audits, payment suspensions, and records requests can be part of, or lead to, a criminal referral. Treat any audit with unusual scope or a payment suspension as a potential criminal matter and get counsel before producing records or giving interviews.

Do not answer questions, and instruct staff that they may decline interviews. Ask for the agents' cards and any subpoena or warrant, preserve all records, and call a lawyer before anything else.

No. The statute provides that a person need not have actual knowledge of the Anti-Kickback Statute or specific intent to violate it. The government must still prove the person acted knowingly and willfully.

No. Fraud requires intent to deceive. Coding mistakes, documentation gaps, and reasonable disagreements about medical necessity are defenses the government has to overcome.

A conviction for a program-related offense triggers mandatory exclusion for at least five years, and licensing boards act on convictions and sometimes on charges alone. These consequences have to be planned for from the beginning, including in any plea negotiation.

A False Claims Act case filed by a private whistleblower on the government's behalf. It is filed under seal while DOJ investigates, and it often runs alongside a criminal investigation.

No. AI documentation tools are lawful. The exposure is a record that describes care that did not happen, or a note signed without review. Creating or completing records after an auditor or payer asks for them can add obstruction exposure under 18 U.S.C. § 1519, which carries up to 20 years.

Yes. We represent healthcare providers and executives in federal investigations and prosecutions nationwide.

Justice Watch Analysis

Med Spa and Compounded Drug Enforcement · 10 min read

Utah's Draft Med Spa Supervision Bill: What Florida Med Spa Owners, Injectors, and Medical Directors Should Read Into It

Own a Florida med spa? Utah's draft bill sets a 60-mile rule for Botox and RN-only injections. See how that same checklist feeds felony charges in Florida.

Healthcare Fraud · 9 min read

South Florida COVID Testing Verdict: Why $15 Million Billed and $500,000 Paid Is a Sentencing Fight

Medicare was billed $15 million and paid $500,000. If you run a South Florida lab or testing business, that gap is a six-level swing. See how loss is fought.

Controlled Substances and Telemedicine · 9 min read

DEA Telemedicine Prescribing Flexibilities End December 31: What Florida Prescribers and Telehealth Platforms Face Before the Special Registration Rule

Prescribing controlled substances by telehealth with no in-person visit? That exception ends December 31, 2026. Audit your 2026 scripts before DEA asks.

Federal Fraud Enforcement · 11 min read

Indicted After Your Company Cooperated With DOJ? What Fraud Division Directive 26-12 Means for Florida Owners and Executives

Your company is cooperating with DOJ. Under Justice Manual 9-28.700 its credit depends on naming every individual involved. Know your exposure before you talk.

Federal Health Care Fraud · 8 min read

A Doctor Who Signed Telemedicine Orders Got Probation, Not Prison: What a Section 1035 Plea Means for Florida Physicians

Signed telemedicine orders in 2020? A Florida doctor just got probation on one 18 U.S.C. § 1035 count. Learn why the charge set before indictment decides it.

Peptide and Compounded Drug Enforcement · 9 min read

FDA Called the Added Vitamin Pretextual: What Templated "Significant Difference" Prescriptions Mean for Florida Prescribers and Telehealth Platforms

Does your significant difference note read the same for every patient? FDA's September 2026 warning letter calls that pretextual. Your exposure, and the fix.

Read all Justice Watch articles

Request a Confidential Review

Confidential. We respond 24/7. Please do not include account numbers or medical records.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. If your matter is urgent, call (561) 542-5494.

The Government Has the Data. Get the Defense Started.

A confidential conversation today can change where the investigation goes. Call now or request a confidential review. We respond 24/7.

This page is attorney advertising and general information, not legal advice. Contacting AMC Defense Law does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Aaron M. Cohen, Esq., is responsible for the content of this page. AMC Defense Law, 1200 N. Federal Highway, Suite 300, Boca Raton, Florida 33432.